Mostrando postagens com marcador Tcacenco Alexandru. Mostrar todas as postagens
Mostrando postagens com marcador Tcacenco Alexandru. Mostrar todas as postagens

quinta-feira, 23 de março de 2017

Wiener Staatsballet: March 22nd, 2017. "Onegin" revisited.


For me Onegin is and always will be one the most sensitive works ever made for ballet. It may sound ridiculous – due to the fact that it is based on Pushkin’s lyrical work – but it is pure poetry... Poetry perfectly translated into ballet by John Cranko, for me until today one of the great genius of last century’s ballet – his work will live forever: I always begin, all over again, to admire immensely his “pas de deux solutions” and group scenes, as if I had never seen them before. And his personal way of building the characters into dance and into the story-telling… more to that a little bit later.

Maria Yakovleva/Roman Lazik: Copyright Wiener Staatsoper/ Ashley Taylor

I was very pleased with the Corps-de-Ballet. Last time I had seen this production I thought that a lot of the precision Cranko put in his work was missing and lots of work should be done: directions, heads and – mostly – arms… that single precision that this South-African brought to life... But yesterday’s performance showed that the company has been working very hard on “style & precision”. And that made me glad! Very glad indeed! So many new faces in the company, which I am not able to distinguish from each other or, better put it this way, faces to which I cannot yet add a name to. I have to write about the ones nobody ever writes about – I have space enough, here on this online platform – and I do not have to reduce my reviews to a few sentences...

Wonderful work by Elena Bottaro (always a joy to look at!), Suzan Opperman, Céline Janou Weder (both such “pros”) and Alaia Rogers (who gave us a beautiful and precise “mirror reflection” of Tatjana – showing through her face all the thoughts, doubts and feelings of the main character! No an easy task). But we all agree that we would love to have a mirror reflection just like Miss Roger's face!

The same applies to the boys – growing very strongly as a group, in complete “unison” with each other.
I have the feeling that between male dancers there are not so many “new faces” and I’d like to mention the names on which an audience can always “rely on” (and put “their feet up and relax because of the good work): Marat Davletshin, Marcin Demp, Alexis Forabosco (that will dance Gremin soon… I guess I’ll have to return to the Opera sooner than I thought!), Igor Milos, Tristan Ridel, James Stephens, Dumitru Taran, Zsolt Törok, Jaimy van Overeem and Géraud Wielick. Dancers you can really rely on. I do not remember – in all years I have been in Vienna, well... decades in fact, following Ballet here in Vienna – to have witnessed a moment in which the male dancers from the Corps-de-Ballet (many half soloists within the names I have mentioned) were so strong together. I like that! Awesome!

Nikisha Fogo, giving her début as Olga, gave a good performance – even though she must have been a bit nervous. But just as the curtain opened I felt that she “had the role” under control: in the scene in which she is doing some embroidery with her mother and foster mother, she was not doing affected movements as a dancer but really putting her strength in the fun of the movement without “pretending”. Sawing... She really was doing her embroidery. Her pas de deux with Lenski was the first “catchy” moment of the evening. Still, there is still some work to be done on this couple's "chemistry". But I am sure they will find it!

Nikisha Fogo/Davide Dato: copyright Wiener Staatsoper/Ashley Taylor.

Davide Dato who hasn’t stopped to delight his audiences – since 6 years (I just found a review that I wrote 5 years ago, in which I said “I am sure that we will be hearing from Mr. Dato very much in the future – I could not have been more right!) is at top form. But I always say this and he always gives performances that are “a notch above” the last one. Always “surpassing” the last performance. A gifted dancer and a very good actor. His Lenski is complete – down to the last details!

Davide Dato/Roman Lazik. Copyright: Wiener Staatsoper/Ashley Taylor.

For me the biggest “gift” of the evening was Alexandru (Sascha) Tcacenco as Gremin. I had never seen a Gremin that possessed such firmness and determination like this portrayal of the role. Dogmatic. Strong. After “decades” of watching Onegin I, at last, understood why Tatjana was so determined, in the last scene, in her way of sending Onegin away from her chambers. At last I understood the “bridge” that Cranko has thought of… the country girl that became the wife of an aristocrat learned also to “command” – because of his army-like behaviour… That is what I meant aat the beginning of this review. The line of story-telling and the way Cranko built his characters. But this was only possible because of Mr. Tcacenco’s performance. A dancer not only with a great stage presence but also with a great “insight” about the characters he’s playing, understanding them completely.


Alexandru Tcacenco/Maria Yakovleva: Copyright Wiener Staatsoper/Ashley Taylor

Maria Yakovleva and Roman Lazik were on their element.

Miss Yakovleva, looking beautifully frail, perhaps in the best role I have ever seen her in, gave us a sensitive portrayal of “haunted” Tatjana – down to the last details. Average audiences will not pay much attention to that – because THESE are no moments of “bravura” (and circus) onstage but, for example, her first “soliloquy” (bedroom scene) was a moment of pure art. The way she lies and moves in bed and then pretends to sleep while her foster mother enters the room, just to stand up a bit later to write on her desk… her thoughts and doubts and wishes symbolized by the mirror and the entrance of Onegin himself, in her dream. Miss Yakovleva delighted the audience – made us sometimes laugh, wonder and then cry… Her interpretation reminded me a lot of the character study that Marcia Haydée (the original Tatjana) did for her work. Insight. As a dancer and actress…
In fact, technique is not all, and those moments, in which the audience is simply “hypnotized” by such a touching performance are more worth than a trunk filled with diamonds and pearls - think about Cunegonde in "Candide".

Maria Yakovleva/Roman Lazik: Copyright Wiener Staatsoper/Ashley Taylor

Mr. Lazik – in the role of his life… that was my impression. And what else could I add to that? Not much. He knows all the dark sides of this character – but also, like he showed in the first act, his “dandy”, bored side. In a very well mastered interpretation, he turned Onegin, who in Russian literature would influence so many other Russian literary characters, into a real person. Flesh and blood. Onegin is a ballet that is not only perfect for him as a character but that also emphasizes his technique and his physique – long legs and very special arms.
A pure joy for Balletomanes – although sad, very sad: think about this quote that Pushkin wrote about Onegin's character: ““..depression still kept guard on him, and chased after him like a shadow - or like a faithful wife.” 

Onegin is a very “round” piece – a form I simply love – precise and compact. There are no “wasted moments”. Thank you, John Cranko!

domingo, 1 de dezembro de 2013

Manon "revisited": 2013, Nov. 28th



Another critic about „Manon”? Just after a few weeks of having written one? Sure?

Yes…

On November 28th I got two (marvelous) tickets for the State Opera, just by the orchestra pit, on the fourth row. This “casualty” made it much easier for me to compare the performance with the one I had seen last October 22nd, which impressed me immensely.

Outra crítica sobre “Manon”? Só poucas semanas depois te ter escrito uma ? Tem certeza ?

Sim…

No dia 28 de Novembro recebi dois (maravilhosos) ingressos para a Ópera de Viena, na área da orquestra , na quarta fila. Esta “casualidade” fez-me mais fácilmente poder comparar esta apresentação com a que tinha assistido dia 22 de Outubro, que muito me impressionou.


It was a great pleasure to see again performances which I had so very liked. For instance Leonardo Basílio’s – a dancer with a brilliant future ahead of him- and Alexandru Tcacenco’s (even though I became suddenly aware that the casting was slightly different: there were four dancers for three roles... but that meant that, even if I’ve missed seeing more of Mr. Basilio, I was compensated by watching a lot of Mr. Dumitru Taran, a very gifted dancer that I very much admire!).

Others that went on delighting me and making me wonder why such supporting roles can sometimes leave a longer, more lasting impression on you than “main roles”, were four of the five courtesans that again gave very witty, intelligent performances: Reina Sawai, Prisca Zeisel, Maria Alati and lovely Eszter Ledán!

Foi um grande prazer rever apresentações da quais tinha muito gostado. Por exemplo as de Leonardo Basílio – um bailarino com um brilhante futuro à sua frente – e a de Alexandru Tcacenco (apesar de dar-me conta que a distribuição de papéis foi levemente alterada: haviam no programa 4 bailarinos para tres papéis… o que significou que, mesmo que eu tenha sentido falta de ver mais de Mr. Basílio, fui compensado por ver bastante de Mr. Dumitru Taran, bailarino muito talentoso e que muito admiro).

Outros que continuaram a me deleitar e fazer pensar porque papéis secundários podem deixar uma impressão tão mais longa e duradoura do que papéis principais, foram quatro das cinco cortesãs que mais uma vez deram interpretações muito espirituoas, inteligentes: Reina Sawai, Prisca Zeisel, Maria Alati e a encantadora Eszter Ledán!


Misha Sosnovschi was again (I wrote a lot about him last time) “the” perfect Lescaut. Chapeau, Monsieur Sosnovschi!

On the other hand magnificent roles like the Beggar’s King and the Warden were not “completely used”, as played by Mr. Marcin Dempc and Mr. Gabor Oberegger. It is, in the particular case of the Warden, very difficult to top Alexis Forabosco’s performance last October.

Misha Sosnovschi foi de novo (Escrevi muito sobre ele na última vez) “o” perfeito Lecaut. Chapeau, Monsieur Sosnovschi!

Mas, ao contrário, magníficos papéis como o Rei dos Mendigos e o administrador da prisão não foram completamente “usados” com a interpretação de Mr. Marcin Dempc e Mr. Gabor Oberegger. É, no caso particular do administrador, muito difícil superar a apresentação de Alexis Forabosco de outubro deste ano.

Alice Firenze… belíssima danzatrice… I use the word “danzatrice” on purpose. Miss Firenze is not only a beautiful, gifted, sensitive dancer but also a very good actress… Miss Firenze gave life to a role that can be very tricky… If not perfectly interpreted it can become dull and boring. But no fear about that when Alice Firenze is on stage. There is always a certain “fire in the air” every time she performs.

She is also the sort of dancer that never leaves a movement unfinished. With a great sense of musicality she even extends certain movements to a maximum length, which I had not seen before… And that is not easy at all during the “drunken Pas de Deux” with Lescaut. A slow one… The fact of appointing Miss Firenze to the soloist category was one of the most well deserved acts during Manuel Legris’ direction period.
I love this kind of talent – not easy to describe in simple, ephemeral words.

Alice Firenze… belíssima danzatrice… Uso a palvra “danzatrice” propositalmente. Miss Firenze não é só uma bonita, talentosa, sensível bailarina mas também uma muito boa atriz… Miss Firnze deu vida a um papel que pode ser muito complicado… Senão perfeitamente interpretado ele pode tornar-se tedioso e maçante. Mas não há perigo disso quando Miss Firenze está no palco. Sempre existe um certo «fogo no ar» quando ela se apresenta.

Ela é também uma daquelas bailarinas que nunca deixam um movimento inacabado. Com seu grande tino musical ela estende certos movimentos ao maximo do comprimento, que eu nunca antes tinha visto… E isto nao é nada fácil durante o “Pas de Deux bebado” com Lescaut. Um que è muito vagaroso… O fato de Miss Firenze ter sido nomeada solista foi um dos mais merecidos durante o período de direcao de Manuel Legris.
Amo esta espécie de talento – nada fácil de ser descrito em simples, efemeras palavras.


Manon and Olga Esina… Difficult to express it in any other way than “they were not meant to each other”. I once read a very clever interpretation of Miss Esina’s stage personality that called her a “Grace Kelly of the Ballet”. It went on to tell us about her remoteness/aloofness and chilly behaviour while performing. That “iceberg condition” in which Grace Kelly mostly existed…

Maria Yakovleva, even totally lacking Miss Esina’s precise technique, was a much more “human” Manon. Not a puppet doing the right things at the right minute.

Sometimes I had the feeling that Olga Esina was just “imitating” feelings… from act to act she went on imitating love, greed, fun, sadness, despair, surrender… That is surely the reason why I prefer her on more contemporary, abstract pieces: they become her much better… She once gave a wonderful performance of “Stravisnky’s Violin Concerto” from Balanchine which I have not forgotten until today – even if that part was immortalized by the great Carol Summer.

Manon e Olga Esina… difícil de expressar isso em outro modo que não seja “elas não foram feitas um a para a outra”. Uma vez li uma inteligente interpretação sobre a personalidade de Miss Esina no palco que a descreveu como um espécie de “Grace Kelly do Ballet”. A crítica continuou a nos contar sobre seu desinteresse, distancia e forma fria quando no palco. Aquele “estado de iceberg” no qual Grace kelly existiu…

Maria Yakovleva, mesmo sem nenhuma da precisa técnica de Miss Esina, foi uma Manon muito mais “humana”. Não uma marionete fazendo as coisas certas nos momentos certos.

Algumas vezes tive a sensação que Olga Esina estava só “imitando” sentimentos,,, de ato para ato ela continuou imitando amor, ganancia, divertimento, tristeza, desespero, capitulação… Esta é a razão porque prefiro-a em peças mais contemporaneas, abstratas: Elas lhe caem melhor… Ela deu uma vez uma linda interpretação am “Stravinsky’s Violin Concerto” que não esqueci até hoje - mesmo que aquele papel tenho sido eternizado pela grande Carol Summer.

But she is completely wrong for MacMillan. Her arms, which are still “too Russian”, were mostly far too high during arabesques and attitudes. Light years afar from the british world of dance. The very same arms were the reason why the last pas de deux (Manon’s death scene) was completely ineffective. They did not let the hands “die” (this is the first hint that audiences get that Manon’s end is near). The hands were too full of energy, not “relaxed dead” how they are intended to be in MacMillan’s choreography (the same way Juliet’s arms are dead in the Tomb scene in MacMillan’s “Romeo and Juliet”).

All this, added to the makeup that made her look like an imitation of Natalia Makarova, made me wonder why other strong dancers in the company did not have the chance to perform this incredible variation of a “beast” – one of my ways of describing Manon (during my last critic I described her as a sort of “Lola-Lola”).
But I must say that her interpretation of the Pas de Trois with Lescaut and Monsieur G.M. (marvelous Thomas Mayerhofer) was superb – a great example of dance in which a lot of emotional remoteness is required…

Miss Esina was the first dancer I ever saw taking her fist curtain calls after “Manon” smiling…

Mas ela é completamente errada para MacMillan. Seus braços, que ainda são «muito russos», estavam na maioria das vezes muito altos durante arabesques e attitudes. Anos-Luz em distancia do mundo de dança ingles. Os mesmos braços foram a razão porque o último Pas de Deux (A cena de morte de Manon) perdeu totalmente em efeito. Eles não deixaram as mãos “morrer” (esta é a primeira insinuação que o público recebe que o final de Manon está próximo). As mãos estevam cheias de muita energia, não «relaxadamente mortas» como elas são destinadas a ser na coreografia de MacMillan (da mesma forma como os braços de Julieta estão mortos na cena da tumba no “Romeu e Julieta” de MacMillan).
Tudo isso, adicionado à Maquiagem que a fez parecer uma imitação de Natalia Makarova, me fez pensar porque outras boas bailarinas na compania ainda não tiveram a oportunidade de interpretar esta maravilhosa variação de uma “besta” – uma das minhas formas de descrever Manon (na minha última crítica descrevi-a como uma espécie de “Lola-Lola”) .

Mas tenho que dizer que sua interpretação do Pas de Trois com Lescaut e Monsieur G.M. (magnífico Thomas Mayerhofer) foi soberba – um grande exemplo de dança na qual distancia emocional é requerida.

Miss Esina foi a primeira bailarina que vi sorrindo durante as primeiras cortinas depois de “Manon”…


Vladimir Shishov… what can I say unless “Premier Danseur”? Mr. Shishov showed us once more this beautiful, rare quality called “right” to be named premier danseur… I have seen many interesting “Chevalier Des Grieux” during my long “love affair” years with the ballet: Dowell, Wall, Legris, Malakhov… more recently here in Vienna Friedmann Vogel and even Roman Lazik…
Strangely enough I understood, at last and after so many years, much more of the character through Mr. Shishov’s interpretation – he gave Des Grieux a special “shine” that had not been there before, especially on the last performances which I had seen here in Vienna:
Youth…

Yes, his Des Grieux is a young man – exactly like he was written by Antoine-François Prévost – and this unique quality brought me to tears at the end of the evening.
Not Manon’s death but Des Grieux’s honest grief. I had never seen such a portrayal…

Vladimir Shishov
… o que posso dizer senão “Premier Danseur”? Mr. Shishov nos mostrou mais uma vez esta rara, bonita qualidade chamada “direito” de ser mencionado como um premier Danseur… Já assisti muito interessantes “Chevalier Des Grieux” durante os longos anos do meu “love affair” com o ballet: Dowell, Wall, Legris, Malakhov… mais recentemente aqui em Viena Friedmann Vogel e até Roman Lazik…
Estranhamente eu entendi, finalmente depois de tantos anos, muito mais do personagem através da interpretação de Mr. Shishov – ele «poliu» especialmente seu Des Grieux de uma forma que não tinha sido visto anteriormente, especialmente nas últimas apresentações que assisti em Viena:
Juventude…

Sim, seu Des Grieux é um jovem – exatamente como escrito por Antoine-François Prévost – e esta única qualidade me levou as lágrimas no final da noite.
Não a morte de Manon mas sim o sincero pesar de Des Grieux. Nunca havia assitido-o assim…